St John House Rentals

Catch ‘n’ Keep

Home - Information Chart - Charter Boats

Outdoor Living

Cottage | 1 Bath | WiFi | Coral Bay

In scenic Coral Bay, ‘Catch ‘n’ Keep’ is a charming, West Indies-style home. Just ten to 15 minutes from nearby white sand beaches, the cottage sits on a half acre of wooded hillside, with a panoramic view of the Carolina valley and its stone sugar mill ruins.

Catch and Keep

Catch and Keep is just what so many budget-minded travelers dream of finding. For less than the price of a condominium, you can experience living in a real island home. The cottage is comfortable, tastefully decorated, and best of all, authentic. The affordable pricing may let you stay longer, or treat yourself to a daysail or massage.

Living and Kitchen

Catch ‘n’ Keep is nestled in a quiet cul de sac off a secondary road with only neighbors passing by, and there is shaded parking right next to the entrance. Well-suited to catch the Tradewinds, the cottage is fully screened and has Hunter ceiling fans.

Living and Bedroom

Six large double doors open onto two covered decks where you can grill out with a Weber gas grill and dine in the fresh air. Or lounge in the hammocks and enjoy the country view, tropical breezes, and beautiful evening sky.


A comfortable queen-size bed with four pillows and lovely cotton linens awaits you.  The bathroom features native stonework in the shower and full amenities.


The cottage is thoughtfully appointed for your comfort and includes guidebooks, WiFI, Cable, DVD and a CD collection, lots of vacation reading, and games. You will also find beach chairs, beach towels, and coolers for your beach days.

Available starting in May 2020

Nightly Rates for Catch ‘n’ Keep

5-night minimum

Apr 1- Aug 31
 Sep 1 – Nov 31
 Dec 1 – Mar 31

Email to Book

Pet-friendly, kids welcome

Driveway Mural

Walkway from the driveway

Weber BabyQ grill

Weber BabyQ grill

Tesla Power Wall

No power outages thanks to Tesla Solar Storage Battery!

A variety of restaurants, eclectic shopping, kayaking, hiking, and live music are conveniently nearby in the Coral Bay area. Not as developed as the Cruz Bay side of the island, you will find Coral Bay less trafficked, more relaxing and exactly your dream of what an island get-away should be like!

Property Location

St John House Rentals, Villas, Cottages and Vacation Homes

Please send an email inquiry from the page of each vacation home of interest. At St John House Rentals our homes are owned or run by a number of individuals and management companies and they all do their own booking. The email link on each home’s page will get you directly to the person who can help! We at St John House Rentals do not do bookings.